1. Home
  2. Studies
  3. More government in the health care system?: Eight theses on a system debate that is budding at an inopportune moment
IW-Policy Paper No. 12 26. May 2020 Jochen Pimpertz More government in the health care system?: Eight theses on a system debate that is budding at an inopportune moment

Among the current challenges of the pandemic, the German health care system has so far proven to be comparatively robust. While the infection rate in Germany is so far slightly lower than in other large European economies, the relatively low mortality rate stands out positively.

Download PDF
Eight theses on a system debate that is budding at an inopportune moment
IW-Policy Paper No. 12 26. May 2020 Jochen Pimpertz

More government in the health care system?: Eight theses on a system debate that is budding at an inopportune moment

IW-Policy Paper

Jochen Pimpertz German Economic Institute (IW) German Economic Institute (IW)

Among the current challenges of the pandemic, the German health care system has so far proven to be comparatively robust. While the infection rate in Germany is so far slightly lower than in other large European economies, the relatively low mortality rate stands out positively.

So far, this is explained by the early onset of contact restrictions. In addition, there are indications that the customarily high frequency of contact between German patients and their physicians, in combination with facilitated conditions for sick leave under the pandemic, also may have had a positive impact on the development to date.  
 
Under SARS-CoV-2, the focus is particularly on inpatient care. Even before, the German health care system was already characterised by a comparatively large number of hospital beds. Particularly the intensive care equipment could be increased – potentially favoured by a mix of private and public hospital operators in Germany. Bottlenecks are more likely to be caused by the staffing of hospitals, where Germany does not compare favourably with other countries. Fortunately, up to now, the system has not yet been subjected to an ultimate stress test.

Against the background of a currently emerging debate on the design of the German health care system, it is worth noting that so far there is no evidence of a lack of medical efficiency among the challenges posed by the crisis, especially with regard to the private sector organisation. Beyond the day, however, misguided incentives that have already been criticised before are still waiting for a solution.  

Download PDF
Eight theses on a system debate that is budding at an inopportune moment
IW-Policy Paper No. 12 26. May 2020 Jochen Pimpertz

Jochen Pimpertz: Mehr Staat im Gesundheitswesen? Acht Thesen zu einer zur Unzeit aufkeimenden Systemdebatte

IW-Policy Paper

Jochen Pimpertz German Economic Institute (IW) German Economic Institute (IW)

More about this topic

More about this topic

Read the article
Älterer Mann arbeitet in seinem Fahrradladen.
IW-Report No. 29 19. June 2026 Ruth Maria Schüler / Stefanie Seele

Abolition of the Additional Earnings Limit

The ageing population in Germany is increasing pressure on the social insurance systems and will (in the future) exacerbate the shortage of skilled labour.

Ruth Maria Schüler / Stefanie Seele IW

Read the article
IW-Trends No. 2 19. May 2026 Jochen Pimpertz / Maximilian Stockhausen

The Reform of Old-Age Pension Systems in Germany

Concerns about the risk of poverty in old age have prompted a multitude of reform proposals, most of which aim to introduce additional redistributive elements into Germany’s statutory pension scheme.

Jochen Pimpertz / Maximilian Stockhausen IW

More about this topic

Content element with id 9713