1. Home
  2. Studies
  3. Single Market Emergency Instrument – An instrument with pitfalls
Hubertus Bardt / Berthold Busch / Christian Rusche / Samina Sultan IW-Policy Paper No. 7 13. October 2022 Single Market Emergency Instrument – An instrument with pitfalls

The Single Market is one of the most important achievements of the European Union (EU) and it contributes significantly to economic welfare. In fact, most of the international trade of the Member States takes place in the Single Market.

Download PDF
Single Market Emergency Instrument – An instrument with pitfalls
Hubertus Bardt / Berthold Busch / Christian Rusche / Samina Sultan IW-Policy Paper No. 7 13. October 2022

Single Market Emergency Instrument – An instrument with pitfalls

German Economic Institute (IW) German Economic Institute (IW)

The Single Market is one of the most important achievements of the European Union (EU) and it contributes significantly to economic welfare. In fact, most of the international trade of the Member States takes place in the Single Market.

However, at the beginning of the 2020 Corona Pandemic, measures were taken that restricted the free movement of goods, services and people. This made it clear that the Single Market is vulnerable and cannot be taken for granted. Furthermore, reduced imports from Russia as a result of the Russian assault on Ukraine have also shown that the EU is partly dependent on supplies from third countries. These dependencies also exist with the People's Republic of China.

Against the background of pandemic and war, the European Commission presented its proposal for a Single Market Emergency Instrument (SMEI) on September 19, 2022. The SMEI aims both at maintaining the Single Market in times of crisis and at supplying the member states, and thus the population, with goods and services affected by a crisis. Maintaining the internal market in times of crisis is very much to be welcomed. In contrast to this are far-reaching competencies for the European Commission for emergencies, which enable dirigiste interventions in the market and thus at least partially invalidate market coordination via the Single Market. This raises the fundamental question of whether the adaptability of decentralized control processes via markets is actually insufficient in times of crisis and must be replaced or supplemented by government requirements. Crisis situations are characterized by particular scarcities - and the efficient handling of scarcities is precisely one of the great strengths of market prices. Thus, if a good can be produced and prices rise accordingly, the potential supplier will use this option. The Corona crisis showed that there was successful and rapid vaccine development due to private entrepreneurial decisions and initiatives that were supported by adequate government framework conditions. Direct state intervention, on the other hand, was not crowned with success. Direct instructions to prioritize the production of certain goods can have unintended consequences: Without strict self-commitment, there is a risk that these war economy structures - with private ownership but state control - will be viewed as normal political instruments. In addition, such measures do not help to break dependencies on third countries in times of crisis.

Download PDF
Single Market Emergency Instrument – An instrument with pitfalls
Hubertus Bardt / Berthold Busch / Christian Rusche / Samina Sultan IW-Policy Paper No. 7 13. October 2022

Single Market Emergency Instrument – An instrument with pitfalls

German Economic Institute (IW) German Economic Institute (IW)

More on the topic

Read the article
Flaggen der Ukraine und der Europäischen Union (EU) mit blauem Himmelshintergrund
Berthold Busch / Samina Sultan IW-Report No. 63 11. December 2023

Fiscal aspects of an EU-enlargement

Following the European Commission's recommendation to open accession negotiations with Ukraine, the European Council will decide on this at its summit in December. This is a historic step that is of great geostrategic importance, particularly in light of the ...

IW

Read the article
Sandra Parthie Event 6. December 2023

Runder Tisch: „Unternehmen in der Bürokratiefalle?”

Der Bürokratieabbau ist zurück auf der politischen Agenda. In ihrer "State of the European Union"-Rede, erklärte ihn Kommissionspräsidentin Ursula von der Leyen jüngst zur Chefsache. Entlastungen für den Mittelstand waren bereits Thema ihrer Rede im letzten ...

IW

More about this topic

Content element with id 8880 Content element with id 9713