1. Home
  2. Studies
  3. Old-age Income Support Instead of a Universal Basic Pension: Reaching the Right Target Group
Jochen Pimpertz / Maximilian Stockhausen IW-Trends No. 3 9. September 2019 Old-age Income Support Instead of a Universal Basic Pension: Reaching the Right Target Group

The proposed universal basic pension (Grundrente) is intended to acknowledge the contribution to society made by indigent pensioners during their working lives. However, a higher pension without a means test would in four cases out of five mean misdirecting aid to those not in need.

Download Studie
Reaching the Right Target Group
Jochen Pimpertz / Maximilian Stockhausen IW-Trends No. 3 9. September 2019

Old-age Income Support Instead of a Universal Basic Pension: Reaching the Right Target Group

IW-Trends

Download Studie Quote

Copy the information

The link was added to your clipboard!

Share this article:

or copy the following link:

The link was added to your clipboard!

German Economic Institute (IW) German Economic Institute (IW)

The proposed universal basic pension (Grundrente) is intended to acknowledge the contribution to society made by indigent pensioners during their working lives. However, a higher pension without a means test would in four cases out of five mean misdirecting aid to those not in need.

Even in cases where the current statutory pension entitlement is lower than the entitlement to basic provision (Grundsicherung), as part of a combined household income the pension still usually succeeds in averting old age poverty. It would therefore make more sense to deduct a personal allowance from the means test, irrespective of the type of income involved. An allowance of up to 200 euros per month would benefit almost all those originally identified as potentially needing assistance if they simultaneously claimed basic provision. However, this would involve the needy being treated differently depending on their individual income in old age. Alternatively, to avoid this unequal treatment, the standard rates of old-age basic provision could be raised for all indigent pensioners. While it would raise the number of potential beneficiaries, this should be interpreted less as an alarm signal than as an indication of an effective old-age pension system. To increase acceptance of income support as part of Germany’s social security architecture, the means test needs to be designed to appear less humiliating.

Download Studie
Reaching the Right Target Group
Jochen Pimpertz / Maximilian Stockhausen IW-Trends No. 3 9. September 2019

Jochen Pimpertz / Maximilian Stockhausen: Eine Frage der Reichweite und Treffsicherheit

IW-Trends

Download Studie Quote

Copy the information

The link was added to your clipboard!

German Economic Institute (IW) German Economic Institute (IW)

Share this article:

or copy the following link:

The link was added to your clipboard!

More on the topic

Read the article
A Systematic Study of Neutrality in Pension Financing and in the Burdens and Incentives for Members of the Statutory Pension Scheme
Jochen Pimpertz IW-Trends No. 4 2. January 2023

„Actuarially Fair” Reductions in Early Retirees’ Pension Benefits

Calls for the reduction in state pension benefits for early retirees to reflect real insurance risks imply that early retirement need not involve any additional costs.

IW

Read the article
Michael Hüther / Jochen Pimpertz IW-Policy Paper No. 6 6. October 2022

Asset accumulation for retirement provision

The pay-as-you-go statutory pension insurance is intended to protect workers in Germany from having to rely on tax-financed assistance in old age. However, due to the ageing of society the security level of the statutory pension insurance must decrease.

IW

Content element with id 8880 Content element with id 9713