While the ECB still struggles with an impaired bank lending channel of monetary transmission, the Fed successfully fought the labor market slack that was caused by the great recession of 2008. Due to the improved labor market, the Fed can now start its gradual interest rate lift-off. The ECB will increase its stance of policy accommodation instead, since low interest rates still do not translate into higher inflation. On the contrary, inflation and interest rates are decreasing in tandem. The reason for the impaired monetary transmission channel was originally the banking and sovereign debt crisis in the Eurozone, but the impairment of monetary transmission is now caused by banks’ reduction in risk-weighted assets, which are an effect of the implementation of the new Basel III capital ratios. Instead of lending to businesses and households banks increased their exposure to sovereigns. This effect is due to the preferential treatment of sovereign debt in bank regulation and is exacerbated by the low interest rate environment. As long as credit growth does not contribute to the growth of money, reducing interest rates even further will not bring inflation back to its target value.

It seems more and more that banks’ capital regulation hinders the credit channel of monetary transmission to function, on which the ECB has to react by further increasing policy accommodation. It seems doubtful that further policy rate cuts into the negative territory will increase bank lending as long as bank lending is restricted by a lack of equity capital. For inflation to return to normal, banks’ capital regulation has to be adjusted in such a way that the credit channel of monetary transmission is working properly again. For achieving this, the abatement of the preferential treatment of sovereign debt in bank regulation is highly necessary.

Based on our analysis, we expect the ECB to cut its main refinancing rate into negative territory and the deposit rate further into negative territory. Moreover, we expect the ECB to enlarge its asset purchase program for one additional year. For the Fed we expect a gradual adjustment of the Federal Funds Rate corridor by 0.25 percentage points at each of the subsequent open market committee meetings.

IW policy paper

Michael Hüther / Markus Demary: IW Monetary Outlook December 2015 – Weak Credit Growth Hinders Eurozone Inflation to Increase

IconDownload | PDF

Ansprechpartner

26. September 2016

Geldpolitik Draghische EntscheidungenArrow

Seit 2008 zieht die Europäische Zentralbank (EZB) ein geldpolitisches Instrument nach dem anderen aus dem Hut, um die Märkte zu stabilisieren, die Wirtschaft zu beleben oder – wie derzeit – die Inflation anzukurbeln. Weil bislang nicht alle erhofften Wirkungen eingetreten sind, soll EZB-Chef Mario Draghi nach dem Willen einiger Ökonomen noch tiefer in die geldpolitische Trickkiste greifen. Doch das ist nicht notwendig. Denn tatsächlich wirkt die Niedrigzinspolitik – auf dem Arbeitsmarkt. mehr auf iwd.de

Zinsentscheidung der Federal Reserve
IW-Nachricht, 22. September 2016

Zinsentscheidung der Federal Reserve Normalisierung der Geldpolitik immer unwahrscheinlicher Arrow

Die US-amerikanische Federal Reserve Bank (Fed) hat die Erhöhung des Leitzinses erneut aufgeschoben. Im vorigen Jahr hatte die Fed ihre Niedrigzinspolitik zwar offiziell beendet. Doch trotz guter Arbeitsmarktdaten gab es seitdem keine weiteren Zinsschritte. Vom „normalen“ Leitzins, der in den USA bei 4 Prozent läge, ist die Zentralbank also weit entfernt – und müsste im Abschwung wie Europa auf negative Zinsen setzen. mehr

The Contribution of Supply and Demand Factors to Low Inflation
IW-Kurzbericht, 20. September 2016

Michael Hüther / Markus Demary IW Monetary Outlook: The Contribution of Supply and Demand Factors to Low InflationArrow

Eurozone inflation underperforms since the beginning of 2013 and monetary policy struggles to stabilize it since then. The items of the aggregate inflation rate indicate that low inflation is due to both supply and demand factors and weak demand is caused by indebtness and unemployment. Additional monetary policy measures are not required in the current situation because monetary policy has long lags when economies are indebted and it already helped to reduce cyclical unemployment. mehr